5 Issues Facing Creators Uploading Video to Facebook

/ Feb 15, 2016

Facebook 360 Degree Video

If you’ve never witnessed a bandwagon effect, then you’re clearly not paying attention to the almost cult-like enthusiasm of Facebook video from the major publishers like Jukin Media, Maker Studios, Fullscreen, Buzzfeed and more. Over the last year, Facebook has increased its footprint in the video space, working with major production studios and celebrities — both digital and traditional — to onboard their video on the platform. They’ve also made a push in the live video space, essentially tackling any and every route towards becoming a go-to destination for any format of video.

The company has announced staggering view counts that, on the surface, trump those of its biggest video competitor, YouTube. But, despite the hype, Facebook has five key issues that are a major setback, both for Facebook and the creators uploading video to Facebook.

      1. Facebook is a Walled Garden for Video Sharing — In a sharing economy where social media and traveling media are crucial to gaining audience, Facebook’s limitations for sharing impact the creator’s incentive to continue uploading natively to Facebook. Currently, once a video is uploaded natively into Facebook, the content is nearly impossible to share outside of the platform. Facebook has led with an embed feature that is accessible via desktop, but this allows the sharer to simply embed the entire Facebook post onto another site. Secondly, Facebook does have an external share link, but finding it is almost impossible. Furthermore, none of these options exist inside the mobile app, where over 500 million Facebook users exclusively access Facebook. Video viewers are able to share, comment, like, as they can on any other post on Facebook, but sharing outside of the platform proves challenging if on mobile.
      2. Facebook_SearchSearch is Impossible — If YouTube has proven strong in one area consistently, it’s search. YouTube has even made a trends report driven by their own search data and user behavior. On Facebook, however, search is an afterthought. After doing a few key search queries, like “Kids React“, a popular series from The Fine Brothers, and “Buzzfeed Video“, neither search turns up the appropriate videos. Further, to navigate to videos takes multiple clicks. Facebook has historically positioned its timeline as the main mechanism for discovery, given one’s friends and pages followed are the “curators” of the video experience, but if Facebook wants to dominate the video game, improved search will be key. Not to mention the UI of its search product is whack.
      3. Like YouTube, Facebook’s Algorithm is Unpredictable — When Facebook first began onboarding video publishers, it also favored its algorithm towards those publishers and natively-uploaded video, in general. Many publishers were even offered extra “boosting” if they would upload exclusively to Facebook or give Facbook first window on the platform. However, according to various industry executives, Facebook has shifted its algorithm and the viewcounts aren’t as staggering as they were initially. Historically, unnannounced or frequent changes to YouTube’s algorithm have stirred controversy and frustration among creators as they attempt to scale their businesses around constantly changing parameters. Creators like Destorm Power, one of YouTube’s early successes known for his fitness videos, rap parodies and original songs, became disgruntled enough that he moved from YouTube to Vine and Facebook, after penning this OpEd: “Can I Count on YouTube?”. This leads us to the next pain point for creators on Facebook.
      4. Monetization — The revenue sharing problem is no secret and one that Facebook was expeditious in tackling as they quickly implemented a rev-share model with publishers. Driving a billion views a month, as was the case with Jukin Media, among others, is fantastic as a business looks to scale valuation and as a marketing vehicle for shows, but when trying to run a revenue positive business, a platform that games views without compensaton is a tough bargain to justify. And various executives in the space claim that the monetization on Facebook isn’t exactly on par with YouTube, yet. The incentive for creators and publishers to keep uploading to Facebook based on view count value alone will likely dwindle as big dollar bidders continue to enter the market.
      5. Freebooting, Lack of Copyright / IP System — Perhaps the biggest issue facing creators who are optimizing their video strategy towards Facebook is that of “freebooting” — essentially illegal uploading of videos, directly in violation of copyright laws. Word of the freebooting problem began to gain steam in early 15 (see the cute video below describing this issue) but caught fire later in the year when YouTube creator Hank Green posted on Medium about Facebook profiting from stolen YouTube content. The result? Facebook announced it would team with YouTube-first media companies Fullscreen and Jukin Media, both of which represent creators and fight copyright infringement on a daily basis on behalf of those creators and their own IP. This is a slow moving process — to create ContentID, YouTube’s fingerprinting tech, from scratch. In the meantime, AudibleMagic, another fingerprint matching technology that identifies music in videos, is the band-aid to the problem. Still hundreds of videos are ripped and reposted on a regular basis, often with dismissive responses by Facebook.  And each of these videos represents significant revenue lost both for the creator and for the publisher, while Facebook still gains revenue on the ads served. Facebook may have staved off the lawsuits, for now, but should more creators get their works hijacked without protection or consequence, it’s only a matter of time before creators rise up.



Tags: , , , ,

  • Gwaed

    Facebook is a big problem as it doesn’t really police any of the content posted on it platform, but same happens on youtube itself. However there should a little more involving copyright laws when sharing content that protect video/ content creators either from their platform or others. I think in terms of youtube, facebook etc as platform/ publisher of content should have more responsibility in managing content posted, their current systems are too lenient. As something needs to change to hold the individuals posting content for profit with out permission or having some sort of lenience or agreement with the original content creator. I think it down to content creators coming together to talk about what can they do to help better protect themselves or even petition for changes to be made in the copyright law or to better enforce it.

  • Adam Cox

    This big question is WHY doesn’t facebook punish repeat offenders on their website? They’re taking the piss aren’t they? They have created the perfect home for thieves and they are willfully allowing the crooks to run the show! The big creators need to boycott until something is done about it! Introduce the copyright strikes immediately Facebook and clean your mess of a site up!

Abrams Artists Entrepreneur Magazine

Why Abrams Artists Opened an In-House Digital Production Studio

Kevin Conroy MGM

MGM Hires Univision’s Kevin Conroy as President of Digital...


YouTube and Telemundo Open Pop-Up Space in Miami


Digital Cabana — Peter Csathy and Jocelyn Johnson Talk...

Industry Tickets Selling Fast!
Click above to lock in your registration for VidCon 2015!
AwesomenessTV Logo Awesomeness

AwesomenessTV Targeting British Youth with ITV Deal

American Crime Story FX Netflix

Netflix Gets ‘Blame,’ ‘American Crime...

Verizon Yahoo

It’s Official: Verizon Buying Yahoo for $4.83B in Cash


Summer Music Festivals and Branded Content

Al Roker

Roker Media Partners with HooplaHa on Live Streaming Originals Slate

Campus Insiders Twitter

Twitter to Live Stream 300 College Sporting Events via Campus...

Comic-Con Logo

Circa Teams with Defy Media’s Clevver for Comic-Con Coverage

International Drone Racing Association ESPN

Drone Racing Gets Dedicated Streaming Channel Drone TV


Amazon and Netflix Alum David Loker Heads to Ayzenberg


CAA Grabs Andrew Graham from Big Frame; Retains Clients as Agent Rep

Machinima Logo

Machinima Takes China with Sohu Partnership

Periscope is Twitter's live-streaming video app

Periscope Adding New Watch and Discovery Features

Transformers Combiner Wars Machinima

Machinima Reveals Voice Cast & Trailer for...


Amazon Unveils 2016 Comedy Pilot Season

Ana Kasparian The Young Turks

The Young Turks’ Ana Kasparian Talks Puke, Vitriol &...

Algorhythm New Form Digital Above Average Craig Benzine WheezyWaiter

What Above Average Plans to Do with $15M in Funding from Turner...

Adam Sandler Ridiculous Six Netflix

Adam Sandler Teams with Oscar-Winner Jennifer Hudson for Netflix...


Video Is Not The Answer (But Great Video Might Be)


Twitter and NBA Partner on Two New TV-Style Shows

BuzzFeed Tasty

BuzzFeed’s ‘Tasty’ Stays Atop Cross-Platform...

Reelio Logo

Reelio Greenlight Serves Up Brand-Ready Influencer Project Database

Kalel Kin Community

Kin Community Coming to Australia

Internet Creators Guild

Is Hank Green’s Internet Creators Guild a Fair Deal?


Netflix Disappoints with 1.68M Net Subscriber Adds in Q2 2016

Star Trek Logo

New ‘Star Trek’ Series Going Boldly with Netflix...

Pokemon Go

The Week In Branded Content


Popsugar Partners with ABC for Political Convention Coverage

Moms With Attitude Awestruck

Awestruck Bringing the World More ‘Snooki and JWOWW: Moms...


Merry Jane Throws Stoned Pokemon Party on ‘Super High...


Netflix Grabs 54 Emmy Nominations, Amazon Scores 16


FULL LIST: Inaugural Short Form Emmy Nominees

Catastrophe Amazon

Amazon Invites ‘Catastrophe’ for 2 More Seasons

VidCon 2016 2

5 Things I Learned at VidCon 2016

Boondoggle ABC Ty Burrell

ABC Revamps Streaming Service with 7 Original Short-Form Series...

BitTorrent News

BitTorrent News to Debut with Republican Convention Coverage

YouTube Money

YouTube Touts Anti-Piracy Efforts as Per-Stream Payments to...